← Back to reviews

Film Review / Clayface

Clayface Gets Under Your Skin

By Sean Gregory Miller, CCO, Darkframe

Darkframe Rating

4 out of 5 skulls
6 min read

Share

I walked out of Clayface wanting to see it again. Honestly, that could be the review. "Would you see it again?" "Yep." Boom. Done. But this film deserves discussion.

I saw it on a Sunday afternoon, two days after it opened, and the theater was packed. Struggling to find a midday ticket for a movie about a villain most people have never heard of is a good sign for DC Studios and for horror.

Going in, I had my doubts. The film belongs to James Gunn's DC Universe, not Matt Reeves' Batman universe, but Reeves is a producer and the movie aims for the same grounded realism as his Batman films. Clayface is traditionally a huge, lumbering mass of living clay, an ambitious character to drop into a world that real. I expected a movie buried in CG. Instead, the effects that make his face melt and his skin sag look great, and they feel physical in a way that sells the whole premise.

What surprised me most was the lack of Batman. There's no cameo and no mention of Bruce Wayne, and I never missed him because every character held my attention. You don't need to know the lore, or even that Clayface is a Batman villain. It works as a monster movie, period.

Still My Favorite Feat of Clay

I've loved this character since Batman: The Animated Series introduced him in the two-part "Feat of Clay." He was the one villain I felt sorry for, and I disagreed with how Batman handled him. Clayface wasn't trying to take over Gotham. He was a man who wanted his life back.

Mike Flanagan has said that same episode is what made him want to tell this story, and you can feel it. Matt Hagen is ambitious and makes bad choices, but he's never greedy, and early on the only person his ambition hurts is himself. That's why you care. Make this a movie about greed and nobody cares what happens to Matt.

The way I see it, Clayface is a tragic hero who crosses into villainy at one moment. He kills John Borrelli, the detective who was right to suspect him, and he does it out of jealousy. Everything before that is a decent man drowning.

Molded by the Method

The treatment Matt takes isn't built to destroy him. Its purpose is to repair damage, and Matt already had a superpower before the first injection. He's a method actor who can become anyone, and the film says so out loud when Matt compares the bio-tech to the way a method actor works.

So the treatment delivers. It fixes his face and perfects his gift, but it can't fix what he's been burying. Years of repressed trauma built unhealthy pathways in his head, and the drug amplifies those too. He fractures until he loses track of which version of himself is real.

It's a deal with the devil. He gets his face back and becomes the greatest actor who ever lived, because he can truly become anyone or anything. The price is himself.

When you are everyone, you are no one.

I dunno if the filmmakers meant all of that, and it doesn't matter. Good art starts conversations nobody planned.

Cast Iron, Down to the Goons

Tom Rhys Harries carries this movie, but casting director Lucy Bevan deserves credit for how strong it is all the way down to the smallest roles.

Look at Szabo's goons. Every one of them looks like he walked out of a Dick Tracy strip. If prosthetics exaggerated their features, the makeup team did a hell of a job, and if not, these guys were born for these parts. They look cartoonish and real at the same time, like Animated Series cels dropped into the present day.

Cinematographer Rob Hardy's camera does the same thing. Shot after shot is framed like a comic panel you could drop straight onto a page.

Pressing Flesh

There were moments I had to look away, and the facial reconstruction scenes were the worst. When Matt cuts his own eyelids open in an airplane bathroom, the woman next to me got up and left. The guys on my other side squirmed through the whole thing.

It's gory but never gratuitous. The horror comes from the music, the pacing, and how far Matt will go experimenting on himself. That's harder to pull off than a jump scare, and it's what separates body horror from a gore reel.

Then there's the kill that gave this review its title. I won't spoil who or how, but it involves Matt's blood doing something blood should never do, and it's the most inventive kill in the movie.

Shapeshifting in the Edit Bay

The human-to-human transformations hit hardest, and Watkins and editor Jon Harris handle them with quick cutaways. We rarely see Matt's body change from one person to another for most of the film. Most of the transformations are handled by the rhythm of the cuts making you feel like you did. It doesn't get much more practical than that.

Those cuts also tell you something about his power. When Matt is calm and in control, he changes in a blink-and-you-miss-it instant, because he's that good at his craft. Once he becomes emotionally unregulated, we finally see the classic swirl of flesh becoming something else. The film never explains any of this. It shows us, and it could have done that with CG, but it chose the edit instead. That's elevated filmmaking on a small budget by superhero standards.

It's one of the oldest tricks in film, from Lev Kuleshov's editing experiments a century ago to Spielberg's broken mechanical shark in Jaws, and it works because the audience does the heavy lifting.

Some reviews say they wanted to see more of the monster. I get the instinct, but seeing the monster does nothing for the character. The restraint is the craft. Horror lives in what you understand, not just in what you're shown.

Where It Got Muddy

The finale is the one place the effects stumble, and it comes down to a single image. Matt's last transformation happens in the rain, and most of that sequence works. The shot that pulled me out was his human face pushing up through the writhing mass of clay. It should have been the most horrifying image in the film, but it read as more digital than anything before it, and for a moment the spell broke.

The final reveal of his full monster form was a letdown too. The design pays respect to the comics and the Animated Series with the sunken eyes and the drooping mouth, but I kept thinking about John Carpenter's The Thing. Rob Bottin's practical work on that film still holds up more than forty years later because it has weight, texture, and real light hitting real surfaces. Practical effects would have made that last shot land harder and hit scarier. Even a physical puppet carrying the close-ups, with digital work cleaning it up, would have matched the craft in the rest of the movie.

Out of the Kiln

Clayface is a solid monster movie built around a man you care about, with great acting, disturbing body horror, and a tragic center that stays with you.

R-rated swings like this only keep getting made when people buy tickets for them, so see Clayface in a theater. Bring a friend who squirms.

Share

Ready to make your own nightmares?